Should I trade 5 one ounce Engelhard bars (and potentially an Aztec 1 oz bar) for a 1/10th American Gold Eagle?

Reddit: r/Silverbugs reports: Should I trade 5 one ounce Engelhard bars (and potentially an Aztec 1 oz bar) for a 1/10th American Gold Eagle?. Full body text was unavailable at ingest time, so this brief is based on headline context.